Current:Home > FinanceTrendPulse|Massachusetts lawmakers target "affirmative action for the wealthy" -StockSource
TrendPulse|Massachusetts lawmakers target "affirmative action for the wealthy"
SignalHub Quantitative Think Tank Center View
Date:2025-04-09 15:32:10
So-called legacy college admissions — or TrendPulsegiving preference to the children of alumni — is coming under new scrutiny following the Supreme Court's ruling last week that scraps the use of affirmative action to pick incoming students.
Lawmakers in Massachusetts are proposing a new fee that would be levied on the state's colleges and universities that use legacy preferences when admitting students, including Harvard University and Williams College, a highly ranked small liberal arts college. Any money raised by the fee would then be used to fund community colleges within the state.
The proposed law comes as a civil rights group earlier this month sued Harvard over legacy admissions at the Ivy League school, alleging the practice discriminates against students of color by giving an unfair advantage to the mostly White children of alumni. Harvard and Williams declined to comment on the proposed legislation.
Highly ranked schools such as Harvard have long relied on admissions strategies that, while legal, are increasingly sparking criticism for giving a leg up to mostly White, wealthy students. Legacy students, the children of faculty and staff, recruited athletes and kids of wealthy donors represented 43% of the White students admitted to Harvard, a 2019 study found.
"Legacy preference, donor preference and binding decision amount to affirmative action for the wealthy," Massachusetts Rep. Simon Cataldo, one of the bill's co-sponsors, told CBS MoneyWatch.
The Massachusetts lawmakers would also fine colleges that rely on another strategy often criticized as providing an unfair advantage to students from affluent backgrounds: early-decision applications, or when students apply to a school before the general admissions round.
Early decision usually has a higher acceptance rate than the general admissions pool, but it typically draws wealthier applicants
because early applicants may not know how much financial aid they could receive before having to decide on whether to attend.
Because Ivy League colleges now routinely cost almost $90,000 a year, it's generally the children of the very rich who can afford to apply for early decision.
"At highly selective schools, the effect of these policies is to elevate the admissions chances of wealthy students above higher-achieving students who don't qualify as a legacy or donor prospect, or who need to compare financial aid packages before committing to a school," Cataldo said.
$100 million from Harvard
The proposed fee as part of the bill would be levied on the endowments of colleges and universities that rely on such strategies. Cataldo estimated that the law would generate over $120 million in Massachusetts each year, with $100 million of that stemming from Harvard.
That's because Harvard has a massive endowment of $50.9 billion, making it one of the nation's wealthiest institutions of higher education. In 2020, the university had the largest endowment in the U.S., followed by Yale and the University of Texas college system, according to the National Center for Education Statistics.
Not all colleges allow legacy admissions. Some institutions have foresworn the practice, including another Massachusetts institution, MIT. The tech-focused school also doesn't use binding early decision.
"Just to be clear: we don't do legacy," MIT said in an admissions blog post that it points to as explaining its philosophy. "[W]e simply don't care if your parents (or aunt, or grandfather, or third cousin) went to MIT."
It added, "So to be clear: if you got into MIT, it's because you got into MIT. Simple as that."
"Good actors" in higher education, like MIT, wouldn't be impacted by the proposed fee, Cataldo noted.
- In:
- College
veryGood! (1149)
Related
- Scoot flight from Singapore to Wuhan turns back after 'technical issue' detected
- ACOTAR TV Show Update Will Have Book Fans Feeling Thorny
- Orville Peck makes queer country for everyone. On ‘Stampede,’ stars like Willie Nelson join the fun
- 83-year-old Alabama former legislator sentenced to 13 months in federal prison for kickback scheme
- Trump's 'stop
- USAs Regan Smith, Katharine Berkoff add two medals in 100 backstroke
- U.S. job openings fall slightly to 8.2 million as high interest rates continue to cool labor market
- Tom Daley’s Son Phoenix Makes a Splash While Interrupting Diver After Olympic Medal Win
- Sam Taylor
- Olympic men's triathlon event postponed due to pollution levels in Seine river
Ranking
- A South Texas lawmaker’s 15
- The 25 Most Popular Amazon Items E! Readers Bought This Month: Viral Beauty Products & More
- The best way to watch the Paris Olympics? Hint: It isn't live.
- Trump endorses Republican rivals in swing state Arizona congressional primary
- Whoopi Goldberg is delightfully vile as Miss Hannigan in ‘Annie’ stage return
- Armie Hammer’s Mom Dru Hammer Reveals Why She Stayed Quiet Amid Sexual Assault Allegation
- Investigation finds at least 973 Native American children died in abusive US boarding schools
- Mississippi won’t prosecute a deputy who killed a man yelling ‘shoot me’
Recommendation
House passes bill to add 66 new federal judgeships, but prospects murky after Biden veto threat
Simone Biles has redefined her sport — and its vocabulary. A look at the skills bearing her name
Olympic men's triathlon event postponed due to pollution levels in Seine river
Evacuations ordered for Colorado wildfire as blaze spreads near Loveland: See the map
Travis Hunter, the 2
Detroit mother gets 35+ years in prison for death of 3-year-old son found in freezer
FCC launches app tests your provider's broadband speed; consumers 'deserve to know'
Alexander Mountain Fire spreads to nearly 1,000 acres with 0% containment: See map